Approaching end of my 7-year/50,000-mile extended warranty term with American Guardian Warranty Services (AGWS). Initial premium: $10,700. Claims history: 4 successful claims totaling $6,913 in payouts, including complete Dometic Penguin 2 AC/HP unit replacement. All maintenance performed per manufacturer specifications.
At 75 years old with uncertain travel duration remaining, evaluating renewal options versus self-insurance strategy. Current consideration set includes AGWS renewal, Good Sam extended service plans, and Warrantech coverage. Recent major components replaced: 6 AGM house batteries (April 2023), 6 Michelin tires with retro-bands (August 2023), dual chassis batteries (fall 2024).
Given positive claims ratio (64.6% recovery) and disciplined maintenance approach, what would be the optimal warranty strategy moving forward? Should I prioritize renewal with proven provider, explore alternative coverage options, or transition to self-insurance given age demographics and asset condition?
Given your positive experience with AGWS ($6,913 in claims vs $10,700 premium) and age considerations, I'd recommend comparing renewal quotes from AGWS, Good Sam, and Warrantech while seriously considering self-insurance given your disciplined maintenance approach.
Based on your excellent track record with American Guardian Warranty Services, where you've recovered $6,913 against your $10,700 premium over 5 years, you're facing a smart decision point at 75 years old with a well-maintained 2020 coach. Your situation is actually ideal for extended warranty consideration because you've proven the value with real claims, especially that expensive Dometic Penguin 2 AC/HP replacement that AGWS covered completely. With your recent major investments in AGM batteries, Michelin tires, and retro-bands, you've addressed many of the typical failure points, which changes your risk profile significantly.
The companies you're considering each have different strengths: Warrantech and Phoenix American through NIRVC offer the advantage of your trusted service relationship, while America's RV Warranty and Wholesale Warranties may provide more competitive pricing. Good Sam's extended warranty program has a solid reputation but tends to be more expensive than independent providers. Given your age and uncertainty about future travel plans, the self-insurance option deserves serious consideration, especially since you've already replaced the most failure-prone components.
Extended warranties become more complex decisions as RVs age because the failure patterns change dramatically. Your 2020 coach is entering the phase where manufacturer defects have likely surfaced, but wear-related failures are increasing. The fact that you've already addressed major electrical components (batteries), tires, and added protective retro-bands shows you understand preventive maintenance, which significantly reduces claim likelihood.
Insurance companies price warranties based on actuarial data showing that RVs in the 5-7 year range typically see expensive failures in air conditioning systems, slide mechanisms, and appliances. However, your proactive maintenance approach and recent component replacements mean you're not a typical risk profile. Companies like AGWS that have a good claims history with you may offer renewal rates that reflect your lower risk, while new providers will price you as a standard risk.
The age factor at 75 is crucial because extended warranties are essentially a bet on future usage and claim frequency. If your travel patterns are decreasing or you're considering downsizing, the mathematical advantage shifts toward self-insurance, especially with a well-maintained coach where you've addressed the major failure points.
Start by calculating your actual risk exposure by listing the remaining high-value components that weren't recently replaced: generator, refrigerator, inverter/charger, slide mechanisms, awning systems, and any remaining original appliances. Research typical replacement costs for these items to establish your maximum potential out-of-pocket exposure. For most 2020 coaches, this total exposure typically ranges from $8,000 to $15,000 depending on the level of equipment.
Contact AGWS first through Camper's Inn for a renewal quote, as they have your complete claims history and know you're a good customer who maintains the coach properly. This baseline quote will help you evaluate other options. When requesting quotes from the other providers, be honest about your recent major replacements and maintenance history, as some companies offer discounts for well-maintained units.
Set up a spreadsheet comparing not just premium costs, but deductibles, coverage exclusions, claim processing reputation, and approved service network. Since you're already working with NIRVC, prioritize warranties that work smoothly with them. Research each company's financial stability through AM Best ratings or similar services, as a warranty is only good if the company remains solvent.
For the self-insurance approach, calculate the annual premium you would pay for extended warranty coverage and establish a dedicated savings account with that amount plus 20% extra as a buffer. Based on your $10,700 over 7 years, this would be approximately $1,800-2,000 annually. This approach works especially well if you're disciplined about funding it and have the liquid assets to cover a major unexpected repair.
If you choose to renew coverage, negotiate with AGWS first using your positive claims history as leverage. Many companies offer loyalty discounts for customers who've had fair claim experiences. Compare their renewal offer against Warrantech and Phoenix American through NIRVC, focusing on coverage details rather than just price. Pay particular attention to coverage limits per claim and annual maximums.
Consider a hybrid approach: purchase a shorter-term warranty (2-3 years instead of 7) with a higher deductible to reduce premiums while protecting against catastrophic failures during your peak travel years. This gives you time to build up a self-insurance fund while maintaining protection during the period when you're most likely to be actively using the coach.
This decision requires consultation with your financial advisor to understand the tax implications of self-insurance versus warranty premiums, especially regarding how RV expenses fit into your retirement planning. A fee-only financial planner can help model the scenarios based on your specific financial situation and travel plans.
Consider getting a comprehensive coach inspection from NIRVC or another qualified facility to identify any potential issues that might influence your decision. This $300-500 investment could reveal problems that would make warranty coverage essential, or confirm that your coach is in excellent condition and suitable for self-insurance.
If you're considering downsizing or changing your travel patterns significantly, consult with RV lifestyle counselors who work with seniors to help plan the timing of major RV decisions. The intersection of warranty coverage, coach condition, and life changes requires expertise beyond just mechanical considerations.
Finally, regardless of your warranty decision, establish relationships with mobile RV technicians in your frequent travel areas. As warranties become more restrictive or if you self-insure, having trusted repair resources becomes increasingly important for maintaining your independence and managing costs effectively.
Help us improve this article by flagging technical issues or inaccuracies.
Was this guide helpful?
Try our free RV calculators and tools to help diagnose and plan your repairs.
Browse RV ToolsWeight calculator, electrical planner, propane estimator & more