I'm dealing with intermittent surging issues on my 2014 motorhome with a Ford V10 engine, and I'm getting frustrated with the seemingly random nature of the problem. Some days it runs absolutely perfect, smooth acceleration and no codes. Other days, especially during acceleration, I get this annoying surging that makes driving unpleasant, and that's when the P0420 code shows up on my scanner.
I've been methodically working through potential causes and have replaced quite a bit already: new MAF sensor, both upstream and downstream O2 sensors, checked fuel pressure (it's good), tested plugs and coils, cleaned the throttle body thoroughly, and even replaced the right side exhaust manifold gasket after noticing some seepage there. Despite all this work, I'm still getting the same P0420 code and surging, and my scan tool consistently points to issues on the right bank.
What's really puzzling me is the connection between the surging and the P0420 code - they seem to occur together. Could there be something I'm missing with the exhaust system that would cause both symptoms? I've already addressed the right side manifold, but I'm wondering if there's more to this V10 exhaust system that I should be checking.
P0420 with surging often indicates exhaust leak affecting O2 readings. You replaced one manifold gasket - check the other side. V10s commonly have issues with both manifolds.
Your 2014 V10's persistent P0420 code suggests several possible causes including catalytic converter efficiency issues, O2 sensor problems, fuel system issues, or engine mechanical problems. While catalytic converter failure is one possibility given your repairs, proper diagnosis should confirm this before replacement. The random surging during acceleration combined with the consistent right-side codes suggests the cat is becoming clogged or has lost efficiency, creating backpressure that's causing your acceleration issues. Since you've already addressed the common upstream causes (MAF, O2 sensors, fuel pressure, ignition components), the catalytic converter is the most likely culprit.
The P0420 code specifically indicates "Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold - Bank 1," which is your left side on the V10 (when facing the engine from the front). When a catalytic converter starts failing, it creates several problems that match your symptoms perfectly. As the catalyst becomes clogged or loses its honeycomb structure integrity, it restricts exhaust flow, causing backpressure that leads to surging during acceleration.
The intermittent nature of your problem is classic for a partially failing catalytic converter. When the engine is cold or under light load, the restricted flow might not be noticeable. But under acceleration when exhaust volume increases, the restriction becomes apparent, causing the surging you're experiencing. The fact that you've already replaced the right-side exhaust manifold gasket and cleaned the throttle body shows you're on the right diagnostic track - you've eliminated the upstream causes.
Your V10 has two catalytic converters, and Ford V10s from this era are known for right-side catalytic converter failures, especially in motorhome applications where they see sustained highway loads and heat cycles. The consistent right-side codes despite replacing O2 sensors confirms the problem is downstream of the sensors in the exhaust system.
For proper diagnosis, you'll need an infrared thermometer to check catalytic converter temperatures, and ideally access to a professional scan tool that can monitor catalyst efficiency in real-time. A backpressure gauge or vacuum gauge can help confirm exhaust restriction. If you decide to replace the catalytic converter yourself, you'll need basic hand tools, a floor jack and jack stands rated for your motorhome's weight, penetrating oil for rusty exhaust bolts, and new exhaust gaskets.
The replacement catalytic converter for your 2014 V10 will cost between $400-800 depending on whether you choose OEM Ford, direct-fit aftermarket, or universal units. You'll also need new exhaust gaskets (around $20-40) and possibly new exhaust bolts if the originals are corroded. Budget 4-6 hours for the repair if doing it yourself, as motorhome access can be challenging.
WARNING: Safety equipment is crucial - exhaust work requires proper ventilation, safety glasses, and heat-resistant gloves. The exhaust system will be extremely hot if the engine has been running, so plan to work on a cold engine or wait several hours after driving.
Start by confirming the diagnosis with a thorough inspection for exhaust leaks, performing a backpressure test to check for restrictions, and then proceeding with temperature testing and scan tool data analysis. With the engine at operating temperature, use an infrared thermometer to measure the temperature before and after each catalytic converter. Temperature testing can provide initial insights, but should not be the sole diagnostic method. A healthy cat may show temperature increases during certain operating conditions, but proper diagnosis requires monitoring catalyst efficiency data with a professional scan tool and comparing actual readings to manufacturer specifications.
SAFETY WARNING: Before lifting the vehicle, ensure you're on level, solid ground. Use proper jack points specified in your owner's manual. Place jack stands rated for your motorhome's weight under designated support points. Never work under a vehicle supported only by a jack. Shake the vehicle gently after placing jack stands to verify stability before working underneath.
To replace the right-side catalytic converter, you'll need to access it from underneath the motorhome. Jack up the vehicle securely and locate the converter between the exhaust manifold and the muffler system. The converter is typically held in place by flanged connections with bolts and gaskets. Spray all exhaust bolts with penetrating oil and let them soak while you prepare your workspace.
Disconnect the downstream O2 sensor wiring connector and carefully remove the sensor from the catalytic converter (you may be able to reuse it if it's relatively new). Remove the bolts connecting the converter to both the exhaust manifold and the downstream exhaust pipe. Support the downstream exhaust system with a jack or exhaust hanger to prevent damage when disconnecting. The converter should lift out, though it will be heavy and awkward in the confined space under a motorhome.
Install the new converter with new gaskets, ensuring proper alignment before tightening bolts. Torque the flange bolts to manufacturer specifications (see your service manual for exact torque values specific to your model year and application). Reinstall the O2 sensor with anti-seize compound on the threads, and reconnect the wiring. Clear the codes with your scan tool and take the motorhome for a test drive, monitoring for the return of surging and checking that no new codes appear.
Given the location and complexity of catalytic converter replacement on a motorhome, many owners choose professional installation. A qualified RV service center or exhaust shop will have proper lifts and tools to access the converter safely and efficiently. They can also perform proper pre-installation diagnosis to confirm the catalytic converter is indeed the problem, potentially saving you from unnecessary parts replacement.
Professional installation typically costs $200-400 in labor, and they'll warranty their work. They can also inspect the entire exhaust system for other potential issues, check exhaust manifold bolt torque, and ensure proper clearances that might be difficult to verify when working under a motorhome on jack stands. If your motorhome is still under any extended warranty, professional diagnosis and repair might be partially covered.
Most importantly, exhaust system work on motorhomes can be dangerous due to the vehicle's weight and size. Professional shops have the proper equipment and experience to perform this repair safely, and they'll dispose of the old catalytic converter properly, as it contains valuable metals that require special handling.
Help us improve this article by flagging technical issues or inaccuracies.
Was this guide helpful?
Try our free RV calculators and tools to help diagnose and plan your repairs.
Browse RV ToolsWeight calculator, electrical planner, propane estimator & more