I'm really worried about making this worse or spending money on the wrong repairs. My 2016 Thor Hurricane with F53 V10 and 15k miles has been surging and throwing P0219 air/fuel imbalance codes. I've already replaced upstream O2 sensors and cleaned the MAF, but the code keeps coming back every 200 miles.
I discovered a potential simple fix: if you have an aftermarket catalytic converter, the issue might be the downstream O2 sensor. There's a $12 spacer (3mirrors Straight 58MM O2 Sensor Check Engine Light Eliminator Adapter) that might resolve this. After installing the spacer and disconnecting/reconnecting the battery overnight, my surging seemed to improve.
Before I let a mechanic start throwing expensive parts at this problem, I'm hoping to understand if others have had similar experiences. Are there safe diagnostic methods I can try that won't risk damaging anything?
V10 surging with air/fuel codes often has cheap fix - vacuum leak, intake gasket, or exhaust leak. Do smoke test or spray test before replacing more expensive parts.
You've discovered the oxygen sensor spacer fix that works specifically for RVs with aftermarket catalytic converters causing catalyst efficiency codes and surging on Ford F53 chassis V10 engines like your 2016 Thor Hurricane. The correct spacer for your model (verify with dealer) slightly repositions the downstream oxygen sensor to reduce direct exposure to exhaust flow, preventing false lean readings that trigger the check engine light. Your experience confirms this fix works - the key is installing the spacer on the downstream O2 sensor (post-cat sensor) and performing a complete ECM reset by disconnecting the battery overnight.
Your 2016 Thor Hurricane's surging and recurring catalyst efficiency code every 200 miles is commonly caused by the aftermarket catalytic converter issue that plagues many RVs. When RV manufacturers or previous owners install aftermarket cats, they often flow differently than OEM units, causing the downstream O2 sensor to read overly lean conditions. This creates a feedback loop where the ECM tries to compensate by enriching the fuel mixture, leading to the air/fuel imbalance code.
The "minor surging" you initially thought was normal driving behavior was actually your V10's computer constantly adjusting fuel delivery based on these false readings. Your experience replacing upstream O2 sensors and cleaning the MAF sensor represents the typical expensive parts-throwing approach that doesn't address the root cause. The fact that you got the exact same catalyst efficiency code at exactly 200 miles on your second trip confirms this is a systematic issue related to catalyst efficiency, not random component failure.
The temporary increase in idle surging you experienced immediately after installing the spacer, followed by complete resolution after the battery reset, demonstrates how critical the ECM reset process is. The computer had learned incorrect fuel trim values over thousands of miles, and needed the overnight reset to return to baseline parameters and relearn proper operation with the spacer installed.
The primary component is an O2 sensor spacer adapter with the correct threading for your model (verify with dealer) in stainless steel construction. These spacers are available at various suppliers for around $12. The spacer is essentially a threaded extension that moves the downstream oxygen sensor away from the direct exhaust flow.
You'll need basic hand tools including a 7/8 inch oxygen sensor socket or wrench for removal and installation, and potentially penetrating oil if the original sensor is seized from heat cycling. Safety equipment includes heavy-duty jack stands rated for Class A motorhome weight (minimum 6-ton capacity) or drive-on ramps specifically designed for RVs, safety glasses, and work gloves since you'll be working around hot exhaust components.
Plan for the repair to take 2-3 hours including cool-down time if the engine has been running recently. The exhaust system needs to be completely cool before starting work to prevent burns. Have a battery terminal cleaner or wire brush available for the ECM reset procedure, and consider having dielectric grease for the battery connections during reassembly.
WARNING: Exhaust components can remain dangerously hot for several hours after driving. Allow the engine and exhaust system to cool completely before beginning work. Always use proper safety equipment including safety glasses and work gloves. Ensure the vehicle is properly supported on level ground with appropriate jack stands or ramps before working underneath.
Begin by ensuring your F53 chassis has completely cooled down. Safely raise and support the RV to access the catalytic converter area, typically located on the passenger side of the chassis. Locate the downstream oxygen sensor, which is threaded into the catalytic converter housing after the catalyst material, not the upstream sensors in the exhaust manifolds.
Using the 7/8 inch oxygen sensor socket, carefully remove the downstream O2 sensor by turning counterclockwise. If the sensor is difficult to remove, apply penetrating oil and allow time for penetration rather than forcing it and risking thread damage. Thread the spacer into the original O2 sensor port hand-tight, then torque to 30-33 ft-lbs (typical Ford specification - verify with service manual) - avoid over-tightening as you're working with exhaust system threads that see extreme heat cycling.
Install the oxygen sensor into the spacer using the same technique - hand-tight first, then torque to 30-33 ft-lbs (typical Ford specification - verify with service manual). The sensor should now be positioned away from its original location, out of the direct exhaust flow path. Double-check all connections are secure but not over-torqued, then lower the RV and prepare for the critical ECM reset procedure.
Disconnect the negative battery terminal and allow the RV to sit for a minimum of 30 minutes (though overnight is preferred for complete reset), though overnight is preferred as you discovered. This extended time ensures the ECM capacitors fully discharge and all learned fuel trim values reset to factory defaults. When reconnecting the battery, clean the terminals and apply dielectric grease to prevent corrosion. Start the engine and allow it to idle for 10-15 minutes while the computer relearns idle parameters, then take a test drive to confirm the surging is eliminated and no check engine lights appear.
While this spacer fix is relatively straightforward for DIY mechanics, several scenarios warrant professional attention. If you're uncomfortable working under your RV or lack proper lifting equipment, have a mobile RV technician perform the installation - most will charge $100-200 for this simple procedure, far less than the thousands typically spent on misdiagnosed repairs.
Consider professional help if your oxygen sensor is severely seized or if you discover exhaust system damage during the repair process. Additionally, if the surging and check engine lights persist after the spacer installation and proper ECM reset, there may be additional issues with your aftermarket catalytic converter or other exhaust system components that require diagnostic expertise.
Your experience highlights the importance of RV-specific knowledge that general automotive mechanics often lack. When seeking professional help, look for technicians familiar with Ford F53 chassis and RV-specific modifications, or reference the detailed IRV2 forum thread you mentioned to educate your chosen mechanic about this common but poorly understood issue affecting many RVs with aftermarket emissions equipment.
Help us improve this article by flagging technical issues or inaccuracies.
Was this guide helpful?
Try our free RV calculators and tools to help diagnose and plan your repairs.
Browse RV ToolsWeight calculator, electrical planner, propane estimator & more